What exactly are “sanity” and “insanity” ?
Wiki says –
Sanity considered as a legal term denotes that an individual is of sound mind and therefore can bear legal responsibility for his or her actions. It is generally defined in terms of the absence of insanity. It is not a medical term, although the opinions of medical experts are often important in making a legal decision as to whether someone is sane or insane. It is also not the same concept as mental illness. One can be acting under profound mental illness and yet be sane, and one can also be ruled insane without an underlying mental illness.
Sanity outside of legal definitions has been little explored by science and medicine, as the concentration has been on illness. Dr. P.S. Graven suggested the term "un-sane" to describe a condition that is not exactly insane, but not quite sane either
I thought I was becoming sane. But now, its all really vague since no one really knows what exactly the word sane means. There are no clear cut definitions anywhere. An absence of insanity, they say, is sanity. So what is insanity. I think that is something that has also been subjected to much research by persons vastly more able than I currently am.
What I had considered to be sane was to have ‘normal’ trains of thought. Go utterly with the flow, ie. I even studied for exams, something that which I never do for internal evaluation exams. Lol! Anyway, the bottomline is that I don’t think I like that kind of ‘sanity’. I am more comfortable acting out the role of the pseudo thinker. Coming to think of it, these pseudo thoughts are something that I crave for now. I appear to have lost that questioning mindset that I used to have, in the past few months.
So this is an exercise which may be entirely futile! Still I guess I can write any amount of utter bull shit in my blog. *angelic*
Destiny is a thing which always arouses my curiosity. Are things pre destined?
A group of people think that everything is ‘written’ or has been pre destined. Another set believes that nothing beats free will and free will is the alfa and omega of everything. A lot of others, frankly don’t give a shit about the concepts at all. Just live. Why grow confused over questions whose answers we might never happen to find out. Heh! I guess its fun just to keep pondering. Who knows, maybe someone will find out the secret to everything one day.
There are a lot of astrologers, seers and people with crystal balls and tarot cards, around the globe. There have also been prophets. Some point out that that the Bible is a huge prophecy, most of whose predictions have occurred correctly. And then there are the Indian astrologers who write the Jaathakam or future of little children based on their times of birth. Most of these concepts are dismissed as quacks and coincidences by logical minds.
But the fact is that there are a lot of predictions which do come true. The people who made those prophecies must have some kind of future sensing powers, at the moment of writing the prophecies, at least. They can also be treated this way – that they are just general projections of the future and would probably occur. It’s a game of poker then. And the accurate prophecy is an intelligent bluff. There is also the approach, where once a person has been shown his/her Jaathakam, he/she might actually try to act out the drama subconsciously, tending to adhere to the predictions. Oh well..Anything can happen.
Coming back to the point, what strikes me is that if some people have been able to predict the future accurately, there lies a possibility of all things being written. We don’t have a say in our lives then. What we consider to be our free choices were actually decided in advance by some intricate system. Everything suddenly becomes a huge system which has specific responses to definite excitations. Nothing’s unpredictable with the system. Free will becomes an illusion then.
I got this point of view from watching the movie ‘Waking Life’. A professor tells the protagonist that –
Think about how it happens. There's some electrical activity in your brain. Your neurons fire. They send a signal down into your nervous system. It passes along down into your muscle fibers. They twitch. You might, say, reach out your arm. It looks like it's a free action on your part, but every one of those – every part of that process is actually governed by physical law, chemical laws, electrical laws, and so on.
So now it just looks like the big bang set up the initial conditions, and the whole rest of human history, and even before, is really just the playing out of subatomic particles according to these basic fundamental physical laws. We think we're special. We think we have some kind of special dignity, but that now comes under threat. I mean, that's really challenged by this picture.
So you might be saying, “Well, wait a minute. What about quantum mechanics? I know enough contemporary physical theory to know it's not really like that. It's really a probabilistic theory. There's room. It's loose. It's not deterministic.” And that's going to enable us to understand free will. But if you look at the details, it's not really going to help because what happens is you have some very small quantum particles, and their behavior is apparently a bit random. They swerve. Their behavior is absurd in the sense that its unpredictable and we can't understand it based on anything that came before. It just does something out of the blue, according to a probabilistic framework. But is that going to help with freedom? I mean, should our freedom be just a matter of probabilities, just some random swerving in a chaotic system? That starts to seem like it's worse. I'd rather be a gear in a big deterministic physical machine than just some random swerving.
(This might be copyrighted stuff…I got this from a screenplay of the movie ‘Waking Life’.. acknowledgements to whomsoever concerned)
Yea yea..whatever!
19 comments:
I'm not sane and I don't care. I reflect the world that created me.
The lines from Waking life seem sane enough. :) Very interesting
Still we would never know. In a simpler version- One movie had this probability "If you had taken the bus, or missed the bus could make a lifetime of a difference?
I think the sane people are the ones in the asylum. They do what they want to do. They talk what they want to say.
We are the insane ones caught in one big chaos of pretention and hypocrisy.
Infact, if you take the word "normal" . Death is normal. Natural. If i say to be somebody "I hope I can do this before I die". Immediate reaction : "Dont say such a thing"
In which case, I'd be claimed as being insecure or of unstable mind!
Which is definitely not normal :)!
The jaathakam is just an indication of the things to come.
One can deviate totally from what the jathakam says.
But if one lives life according to the jathakam, it is quite possible that some of the indications can turn out to be true.
@ enemy of the republic -
ur attitude is admirable.
we are all mirrors which reflect what the world has done to us.
@ incognito -
the script of 'waking life' is excellent. try to see that movie if possible. its even better :)
u know what. i also have had this feeling that the really sane persons have all been committed in asylums. this world is crazy. unless u tap to its tune, ur also crazy :D
@ darth|duttan -
i don't know. :) i am ignorant.
Everything is just a charade. But then that doesnt mean we cant feel anything. We do feel a lot of things. I believe thats what matters now, TO THE INDIVIDUAL. If that too doesnt matter. Then Its completely nihilistic proposition.
Ofcourse its better to try and fail to understand these things as you will have gone that much distance in one respect or the other.
And about the mirror, We are all fogged warped mirrors only not perfect mirrors. Actually no where near perfect MIRRORS.
Vrey interesting read Posion...wow!
Sanity IMO is opposite of Keshi..lol!
**What we consider to be our free choices were actually decided in advance by some intricate system.
thats a very inetresting view of it...I dunno how true it can be but it sounds vey convincing...cos that wud explain the many WHYs in my mind...d u think this can be true?
Keshi.
Thats more like you.
First of tats an awesome movie. And abt destiny....well I am not sure anymore...my fav quote ever says,'destiny is not a matter of chance but a mater of choice'......but what choice.choice between options that get thrown your way by 'chance'.....
Well, I think I kind of belong to the class of people who really dont care about the answers.....I have my today.I might have my tommorow...Everything else mite or mite not add up!!!
HA!! I can write more junk,but have to get somwhere......buhbyeee!!
Catchya later!
TC,
Divs
We all are insane unless proved otherwise ;)
GBU
Arti
physical law, chemical laws, electrical laws?? wooow ^^
i never thought of them. thank u very much for the eye-opening post!!
sanity and insanity....no one can really define these terms. what is sane to me, is insane to someone else and what is sane to someone else, might be insane to me...
but i do believe in what a wise man called Philip K. Dick said:
"sometimes the appropriate response to reality is to go insane" :)
interesting write up. :)
>>What exactly are “sanity” and “insanity” ?
in case u havnt yet got an anser:
insanity:- being u
sanity:- being me
:_D
wow..!!
wonderful post..!!
:))
I needed to add this, we havent defined what is random. All those things we cant explain are usually taken as random.. Then we work to find the correlation and whatever. And funnier still is we think that we can use a probablisitic system to define possibilities. Maybe these are a part of still larger much more complex system. Who knws..
About the brain, i would say that the workings of the brain that is how the "Neural network" of the brain functions has not been exactly found. Which means that we are talking again about two probable theories that can be applied to thought :P. How about that.
Gave up on the physics part.
what is sanity?: absence of insanity.
So, what is insanity? : absence of sanity.
There are very few things quite uncomplicated as this, now :p
@ aravind v -
:) i am skewed towards nihilism these days. mirrors...i think that we can see that everything is perfect in its own weird way if we look hard enough.
@ keshi -
well..this could be true :)
i dont know..heck, no one knows :D
@ invincible -
:P
@ divya -
write more junk! :D
wud love to read it! choices...they lose their meaning if they are really pre determined by the first event in the system..
@ arti -
yep! amen to that :D
@ niki chan -
try to get that movie 'waking life' and give it a try :)
@ illusion -
that philip k dick was indeed a wise man! lol :) its a crazy world!!
@ geo -
thettanenkilum saramilla ;)
@ hope and love -
:D
@ aravind v -
yep..'probably' all the random happenings are really deterministic
:-S
@ spawn -
@-) :-J
@ mridula -
hehe! was simple really..just some demo words shrouding the content
@ alit -
damn right!
its as simple as that! ^:)^
But then again what we call as deterministic might not be deterministic at all..
Post a Comment